Heated debate over debt ceiling derails bank failure oversight hearing

 

Bill Huizenga
Rep. Bill Huizenga, R-Mich., chair of the House Financial Services oversight panel, implored members of the committee "to behave as adults" after a hearing on recent bank failures devolved into a shouting match over the debt ceiling impasse.
Bloomberg News

WASHINGTON — In several exchanges that reflected the increasingly tense atmosphere over the debt ceiling on Capitol Hill, Republican leadership in the House Financial Services Committee tried to steer the narrative of a hearing on the recent regional bank failures toward their criticisms of the Federal Reserve. 

President Joe Biden has escalated his public battle over the debt ceiling, specifically targeting Wall Street, and Democratic lawmakers appeared to be following his lead. 

Yesterday, Biden accused Republicans of "holding the economy hostage" in a speech in Valhalla, New York, a narrowly GOP-held suburb of New York City that serves as home base for many Wall Street and financial commuters into the city. Similarly, Democratic lawmakers sought to make their points on the debt ceiling during a House Financial Services Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee hearing on the recent Government Accountability Office report on regional bank failures. 

At the hearing, a spat over time allotted over the typical five minutes given to each member of a committee for questioning — along with a point of parliamentary order over how it's appropriate to refer to other members of Congress — gave way to a rowdy argument between Democratic and Republican lawmakers. 

Rep. Steven Horsford, D-Nev., used his time to try to draw parallels over the failed management of Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank and First Republic to the ongoing negotiations over the debt ceiling. 

"I think that while we do our jobs examining Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank and First Republic Bank, we should actually do our job as Congress and avoid this major catastrophe that is weeks away," he said. 

Rep. Ann Wagner, R-Mo., interrupted Hosford's comments with a point of parliamentary order after he referred to Senate minority leader Mitch McConnell's, R-Ky., role in stalling debt ceiling negotiations. But Rep. Bill Huizenga, R-Mich., who chaired the subcommittee hearing, didn't find Wagner's point valid. However, the exchange deteriorated as Horsford and Huizenga began speaking over each other. 

"The chair will not accept this behavior," Huizenga said. "I let a line of questioning go for an answer that was along the line of the ranking member. I allowed you to have a full minute." 

He continued: "I expect that we are going to behave as adults at this table as you are demanding that Congress act, so lead by example everybody." 

Rep. Maxine Waters, D-Calif., ranking member of the full committee, continued to escalate the tone of the conversation. 

"I would caution you not to imply that our members are not acting like adults," she said. 

Huizenga said his comment was directed to "all sides." 

"Let's present to the American people that we can actually act like adults at this table," Huizenga retorted. 

Waters responded: "I think we are. We don't need you to admonish us." 

Republicans, meanwhile, tried to pin down the hearing's sole witness, Michael Clements, director of financial markets and community investment at the GAO, on his criticisms of the Fed's oversight of Silicon Valley Bank

Specifically, Huizenga took issue with the Fed report's suggestion that former Vice Chair for Supervision Randal Quarles primarily drove changes to the Fed's culture that resulted in lax oversight of the failed bank. 

"I have no way to say if there was a culture shift in one way or the other," Clements said. "Again, we had the single meeting with the Fed [and] the issue of culture wasn't brought up. In fairness, we didn't ask it, but they didn't bring it up either." 

"But it features prominently in their report that there was this culture shift," Huizenga said. "It seems a little odd to me that they would not have brought that up in your investigation." 

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Politics and policy Banking Crisis 2023
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER