Bank M&A deals substantially bigger in 2024

Independent Financial office in Houston
The largest bank deal of 2024 so far was Winter Haven, Florida-based SouthState Corp.'s $2 billion bid to acquire Independent Bank Group in McKinney, Texas.
Adobe Stock

Bank merger-and-acquisition activity remains relatively light, but the deals that came together in recent months were, in aggregate, substantially larger.

As of June 14, there were 27 bank deals worth $5.45 billion announced in the second quarter. That total eclipsed the $5.2 billion combined deal value of the 126 bank deals announced over the preceding five quarters, according to S&P Global Market Intelligence's latest tally.

Through mid-June, there were a total of 54 bank M&A transactions announced this year with a total deal value of $6.5 billion. The volume of deals put the industry on pace to top last year's 99, but it would still fall far short of the 156 announced in 2022 and the 202 combinations inked in 2021, the S&P Global data shows.

Total value, however, is on pace to far surpass the $4.15 billion worth of deals announced last year and the $8.95 billion announced a year earlier, though it would still fall shy of the $76.7 billion total in 2021.

The largest deal of 2024 so far was Winter Haven, Florida-based SouthState Corp.'s $2 billion bid to acquire Independent Bank Group in McKinney, Texas. Independent has $18.9 billion of assets, $15.7 billion of deposits and $14.6 billion of loans. 

That deal edged out Kansas City, Missouri-based UMB Financial's almost $2 billion all-stock plan to acquire Heartland Financial USA in Denver.

SouthState had made several acquisitions in recent years, but the Independent deal marked its first since early 2022, when it acquired Atlantic Capital Bancshares. SouthState CEO John Corbett said during a call with analysts after the Independent deal was announced last month that the company remains open to more M&A, particularly in high-growth markets such as Texas.

"We've been accumulating excess capital and building reserves above our peers so that we have the dry powder to invest when the time is right," Corbett said.

In a midyear M&A outlook, PwC's research team said bigger banks are hunting for strategic options to attain additional scale, better manage costs, diversify business lines and expand geographically.

"In a fast-changing and competitive market, banks need to be proactive" and "agile to capture value and growth," said Dan Goerlich, PwC's U.S. banking and capital markets leader. 

Still, deal volume is only slowly gathering momentum following the Federal Reserve's campaign to push interest rates higher over the past two years to tame inflation. High borrowing costs slowed banks' loan growth and business owners' new investments, raising recession worries. Lofty rates also drove up banks' deposit costs and contributed to uncertainties that made it difficult for bank buyers to assess the health of targets.  

A string of three regional bank failures in 2023 added to the uncertainty. The collapses also galvanized federal policymakers to further ratchet up regulatory reviews to prevent future failures, analysts said. This came atop the Biden administration's policy of increased M&A regulatory scrutiny. Lengthy review periods have delayed dozens of bank deals this decade. Several were nixed altogether.  

Most recently, two Louisiana banks called off their plan to merge earlier this month. When MC Bancshares in Morgan City and Heritage NOLA Bancorp in Covington announced their intention to combine in July 2023, they targeted a closing by the end of the year. But the review process dragged deep into 2024.

Following an "extensive review of the current uncertainties in the regulatory environment and merger approval process, the board concluded that it was no longer in the stockholders' best interest to continue to pursue the proposed merger," David Crumhorn, Heritage president and CEO, said in a statement.

For all the potential roadblocks, analysts noted that the Fed has not raised rates since July of last year. Policymakers have signaled that their next move most likely will be a rate reduction, given that inflation fell from a peak above 9% in 2022 to nearly 3% this year.

At the same time, recession fears proved overblown. The economy grew throughout 2023 and the first quarter of this year. The Atlanta Federal Reserve Bank estimated that U.S. gross domestic product is expanding at a 3% rate in the current quarter.

Fed Chair Jerome Powell noted in a press conference after policymakers' June meeting that he still wants greater confidence that inflation "is moving sustainably towards 2%" before lowering rates. But he also emphasized that inflation is modestly moving toward the Fed's objective while the economy remains healthy.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Bank Stats M&A Community banking
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER